[pronut-hiv] Caught in a dilemma: mother to child HIV transmission in Zambia

[<pronut-hiv@healthnet.org>]

Caught in a dilemma: mother to child HIV transmission in Zambia 

With one third of mother-to-child transmission of HIV (MTCT) occurring through breast-feeding, advice not to breast-feed appears sensible, and is standard practice in well-resourced countries.  However in poorly resourced environments breast-feeding offers substantial advantages to all infants in protecting against infectious diseases such as gastrointestinal infection, meningitis, sepsis and bronchiolitis. 

This advantage has to be balanced against the risk of MTCT. Studies to date have not identified improved survival of infants fed on 'formula' alone, even where this, the safest breast milk substitute (BMS), has been provided free.

There is evidence that exclusive breast-feeding (EBF) for at least 3 months after birth (when the baby is at most risk) has significantly lower rates of MTCT than mixed feeding, where fluids and foods are introduced early into the infant's diet along with breast milk. This concords with the WHO recommendation for infants to exclusively breastfeed to 6 months.

The Liverpool School of Tropical Medicine examined mothers' actual infant feeding practice in Zambia in 2000.  Fifty five mothers who knew they had HIV were compared to 85 mothers who knew they were not infected.  The options of formula or modified cow's milk BMS, or exclusive breastfeeding were given.

In this study, HIV-infected mothers:

all breast-fed their infants 
introduced fluids earlier 
introduced complementary foods (porridges) earlier 
were less likely to EBF to 2 or 4 months 
more frequently used cow's milk as a BMS than uninfected peers 
had infants with a lower average weight for their age. 
Furthermore the eight mothers using cow's milk based BMS never modified this as recommended.  No mother added water, one added sugar and three were adding salt. The addition of salt to infant feeds is particularly dangerous, and suggests confusion with making oral rehydration fluids.

In 2003, this project was repeated at a different prevention of MTCT (PMTCT) site in Zambia. Although adherence to the feeding choices of either EBF or formula was better, mothers were still slower to give the first breast-feed after birth, and introduced fluids and foods earlier. Again we found salt was being added to cow's milk. More positively we found a supportive partner was associated with mothers adhering to their initial feeding choice.

There is a need to reflect on the actual practices of mothers in PMTCT programmes, to inform policy and its implementation. Even in formal PMTCT programmes mothers may translate knowledge acquired into incorrect practice, which may be extremely harmful to their child.  Messages on feeding choice are not easy to give and counsellors are usually busy and often overwhelmed with work. In low resource environments, it remains difficult to provide an acceptable, affordable or safe BMS and for many EBF remains the best option.  Ongoing support to mothers to adhere to their chosen feeding option is critical and may be better provided by peer counsellors in the community, than health professionals.

Contributor(s): James Bunn

Source(s):
'Infant-feeding practices of mothers of known HIV status in Lusaka, Zambia', Health Policy and Planning 18: 156-162, by A.A. Omari, C. Luo, C. Kankasa, G.J. Bhat, and J. Bunn, 2003 
'Free formula milk for infants of HIV-infected women: blessing or curse?', Health Policy and Planning 17: 154-160, by A Coutsoudis, A.E. Goga, N. Rollins, and H.M. Coovadia (on behalf of the Child Health Group), 2002


Funded by: Liverpool School of Tropical Medicine 

id21 Research Highlight: 25 September 2003

Further Information:
James Bunn
Liverpool School of Tropical Medicine
Pembroke Place
Liverpool L3 5QA
UK

Email: jegbunn@liverpool.ac.uk

Liverpool School of Tropical Medicine (LSTM), UK





Dorcas Lwanga MSc, RD
Nutritionist
SARA Project
Academy for Educational Development
1825 Connecticut Ave. NW
Washington, DC 20009-5721 USA

Tel. (202) 884-8815
Fax. (202) 884-8447

Be someone who listens and you will be heard. Be someone who care and you will be loved. Be someone who gives, and you will be blessed. Be someone who comforts, and you will know peace.
Be someone who genuinely seeks to understand , and you will be wise. Be someone who is kind, someone considerate, and you will be admired. Be someone who values truth, and you will respected. 
Be someone who takes action, and you will move life forward. Be someone who lifts others higher, and your life will be rich. Be someone filled with gratitude, and there will be no end to the things for which you'll be thankful. 
Ralph Marston.

--
ProNut-HIV is a collaboration between SATELLIFE and the Academy for
Educational Development (AED).

To send a message to ProNut-HIV, write to: pronut-hiv@healthnet.org
To subscribe or unsubscribe, write to: majordomo@healthnet.org
in the body of the message type: subscribe pronut-hiv OR unsubscribe
pronut-hiv
To contact a person, send a message to: pronut-hiv-help@healthnet.org
Information and archives: http://www.pronutrition.org